
|
Comparison of Face-to-Face and Video-Mediated Communications with Deaf Individuals Michael J. Gournaris, Psychology Telecommunications media,
such as telephones and videoconference systems are increasingly replacing
face-to-face communication. The implications for mental health care are
only now beginning to be evident. Video-mediated communication (VMC) potentially
offers us the benefits of face-to-face communication over long distances.
Researchers need to develop more studies to assess the effectiveness of
the VMC process with deaf individuals. The aim of this proposed study is
to compare performance and effects on communication in face-to-face and
VMC situations for deaf individuals, The evaluation of task performance
will be based on video and face-to-face modalities using a Map Task in
which a deaf instructor using American Sign Language describes map directions
to deaf subjects who mark routes as instructed. The Map Task assesses the
performance of subjects on two collaborative problem-solving tasks. The
purpose of the Map Task is to elicit natural, spontaneous, and yet content-controlled
dialogues. The conversations between deaf speakers in different rooms linked
by high-quality analogue video will be compared to face-to-face communication
to see if VMC will deliver the same efficiency benefits as face-to-face
situations. The results may have profound implications for mental health
service delivery to deaf individuals in areas that lack mental health service
providers who can communicate effectively with this population.
|